2004-12-1 Bill C-5, An Act to provide financial assistance for post-secondary education savings (report stage amendment)
Site Votes:250 (-216 For)
| Vote | Name | Telephone | Party | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| nay | Allison | 613-995-2772 | dean.allison@parl.gc.ca | Conservative |
| yea | Angus | 613-992-2919 | charlie.angus@parl.gc.ca | NDP |
| nay | Bennett | 613-995-9666 | carolyn.bennett@parl.gc.ca | Liberal |
| nay | Bezan | 613-992-2032 | james.bezan@parl.gc.ca | Conservative |
| nay | Fry | 613-992-3213 | hedy.fry@parl.gc.ca | Liberal |
| nay | Gallant | 613-992-7712 | cheryl.gallant@parl.gc.ca | Conservative |
| nay | Holland | 613-995-8042 | mark.holland@parl.gc.ca | Liberal |
| yea | Julian | 613-992-4214 | peter.julian@parl.gc.ca | NDP |
| nay | LeBlanc | 613-992-1020 | dominic.leblanc@parl.gc.ca | Liberal |
| nay | MacAulay | 613-995-9325 | lawrence.macaulay@parl.gc.ca | Liberal |
| nay | MacKenzie | 613-995-4432 | dave.mackenzie@parl.gc.ca | Conservative |
| yea | Masse | 613-996-1541 | brian.masse@parl.gc.ca | NDP |
| nay | McGuinty | 613-992-3269 | david.mcguinty@parl.gc.ca | Liberal |
| nay | McKay | 613-992-1447 | john.mckay@parl.gc.ca | Liberal |
| nay | Moore | 613-996-2332 | Rob.Moore@parl.gc.ca | Conservative |
| nay | Plamondon | 613-995-9241 | louis.plamondon@parl.gc.ca | Bloc Québécois |
| nay | Poilievre | 613-992-2772 | pierre.poilievre@parl.gc.ca | Conservative |
| nay | Reid | 613-947-2277 | scott.reid@parl.gc.ca | Conservative |
| nay | Rodriguez | 613-995-0580 | pablo.rodriguez@parl.gc.ca | Liberal |
| nay | Scarpaleggia | 613-995-8281 | francis.scarpaleggia@parl.gc.ca | Liberal |
| nay | Scheer | 613-992-4593 | Conservative | |
| nay | Sgro | 613-992-7774 | judy.sgro@parl.gc.ca | Liberal |
| nay | Bergeron | 613-996-2416 | Stephane.Bergeron@parl.gc.ca | Bloc Québécois |
| nay | Bagnell | Liberal | ||
| nay | Bains | Liberal | ||
| nay | Easter | Liberal | ||
| nay | Lukiwski | Conservative | ||
| nay | Ratansi | Independent | ||
| nay | Regan | Liberal | ||
| nay | Simms | Liberal | ||
| nay | Casey | Liberal | ||
| yea | Cullen | NDP | ||
| nay | Goodale | Liberal | ||
| nay | Paradis | Liberal | ||
| nay | Rota | 613-995-6255 | anthony.rota@parl.gc.ca | Liberal |
| nay | Sorenson | Conservative | ||
| Wrzesnewskyj | Liberal | |||
| nay | Anderson | Conservative | ||
| yea | Christopherson | NDP | ||
| nay | Cuzner | Liberal | ||
| nay | Miller | Conservative | ||
| nay | Nicholson | Conservative | ||
| nay | Tilson | Conservative | ||
| nay | Trost | Conservative | ||
| nay | Lauzon | Conservative | ||
| nay | Obhrai | Conservative | ||
| nay | Warawa | Conservative | ||
| nay | Brison | Liberal | ||
| nay | Van Loan | Conservative | ||
| nay | Brown | Conservative | ||
| nay | Ambrose | Conservative | ||
| nay | Ritz | Conservative | ||
| nay | Dion | Liberal | ||
| nay | McCallum | Liberal | ||
| nay | Kenney | Conservative | ||
| nay | Bélanger | Liberal | ||
| nay | Benoit | Conservative | ||
| nay | Boivin | NDP | ||
| nay | Cotler | Liberal | ||
| yea | Crowder | NDP | ||
| nay | Devolin | Conservative | ||
| nay | Duncan | Conservative | ||
| nay | Fletcher | Conservative | ||
| yea | Godin | NDP | ||
| nay | Goodyear | Conservative | ||
| nay | Grewal | Conservative | ||
| nay | Harris | Conservative | ||
| nay | Hiebert | Conservative | ||
| nay | Kramp | Conservative | ||
| nay | Lunney | Independent | ||
| nay | MacKay | Conservative | ||
| nay | Moore | Conservative | ||
| nay | O'Connor | Conservative | ||
| nay | Preston | Conservative | ||
| nay | Rajotte | Conservative | ||
| nay | Schellenberger | Conservative | ||
| yea | Stoffer | NDP | ||
| nay | Vellacott | Conservative | ||
| nay | Yelich | Conservative | ||
| nay | Anders | Conservative | ||
| nay | Bellavance | Independent | ||
| yea | Comartin | NDP | ||
| yea | Davies | NDP | ||
| nay | Komarnicki | Conservative | ||
| nay | Pacetti | Independent | ||
| nay | Smith | Conservative | ||
| nay | Merrifield | Conservative | ||
| nay | Karygiannis | Liberal | ||
| nay | Jean | Conservative | ||
| nay | Menzies | Conservative | ||
| nay | Toews | Conservative | ||
| nay | Tweed | Conservative | ||
| nay | Coderre | Liberal | ||
| nay | Oda | Conservative | ||
| nay | Richardson | Conservative | ||
| yea | Layton | NDP | ||
| nay | Abbott | Conservative | ||
| nay | André | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | Asselin | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | Bachand | Bloc Québécois | ||
| Bigras | Bloc Québécois | |||
| Blais | Bloc Québécois | |||
| nay | Bouchard | Bloc Québécois | ||
| Bourgeois | Bloc Québécois | |||
| nay | Brunelle | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | Cannis | Liberal | ||
| nay | Carrier | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | Casson | Conservative | ||
| nay | D'Amours | Liberal | ||
| nay | Day | Conservative | ||
| nay | Demers | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | Dhalla | Liberal | ||
| nay | Dosanjh | Liberal | ||
| nay | Dryden | Liberal | ||
| Duceppe | Bloc Québécois | |||
| nay | Gagnon | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | Guarnieri | Liberal | ||
| nay | Guay | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | Guergis | Independent Conservative | ||
| nay | Jennings | Liberal | ||
| nay | Laframboise | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | Lalonde | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | Lavallée | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | Lee | Liberal | ||
| nay | Lemay | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | Lessard | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | Lévesque | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | Lunn | Conservative | ||
| nay | Malhi | Liberal | ||
| yea | Martin | NDP | ||
| nay | McTeague | Liberal | ||
| nay | Ménard | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | Minna | Liberal | ||
| Murphy | Liberal | |||
| nay | Neville | Liberal | ||
| nay | Paquette | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | Patry | Liberal | ||
| nay | Proulx | Liberal | ||
| nay | Savage | Liberal | ||
| yea | Siksay | NDP | ||
| nay | Silva | Liberal | ||
| nay | Szabo | Liberal | ||
| nay | Tonks | Liberal | ||
| nay | Volpe | Liberal | ||
| nay | Wilfert | Liberal | ||
| nay | Deschamps | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | Guimond | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | Martin | Liberal | ||
| nay | Prentice | Conservative | ||
| nay | Hill | Conservative | ||
| Roy | Bloc Québécois | |||
| nay | Bevilacqua | Liberal | ||
| nay | Ménard | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | Batters | Conservative | ||
| nay | Bell | Liberal | ||
| nay | Comuzzi | Conservative | ||
| nay | Fitzpatrick | Conservative | ||
| nay | Hanger | Conservative | ||
| nay | Jaffer | Conservative | ||
| nay | Khan | Conservative | ||
| nay | Marleau | Liberal | ||
| yea | McDonough | NDP | ||
| nay | Perron | Bloc Québécois | ||
| Picard | Bloc Québécois | |||
| nay | Redman | Liberal | ||
| nay | Skelton | Conservative | ||
| nay | Solberg | Conservative | ||
| nay | St-Hilaire | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | Boshcoff | Liberal | ||
| nay | Brown | Liberal | ||
| nay | Chan | Liberal | ||
| nay | Doyle | Conservative | ||
| nay | Emerson | Conservative | ||
| nay | Godfrey | Liberal | ||
| nay | Hubbard | Liberal | ||
| nay | Kadis | Liberal | ||
| nay | Karetak-Lindell | Liberal | ||
| nay | Mills | Conservative | ||
| nay | Scott | Liberal | ||
| nay | Simard | Liberal | ||
| nay | St. Amand | Liberal | ||
| nay | St. Denis | Liberal | ||
| nay | Telegdi | Liberal | ||
| nay | Thibault | Independent | ||
| nay | Bonin | Liberal | ||
| nay | Cullen | Liberal | ||
| nay | Valley | Liberal | ||
| nay | Williams | Conservative | ||
| nay | Zed | Liberal | ||
| nay | Maloney | Liberal | ||
| nay | Barnes | Liberal | ||
| nay | Matthews | Liberal | ||
| nay | Temelkovski | Liberal | ||
| Martin | Liberal | |||
| nay | Steckle | Liberal | ||
| nay | Pallister | Conservative | ||
| nay | Stronach | Liberal | ||
| Wappel | Liberal | |||
| yea | Blaikie | NDP | ||
| nay | Kotto | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | Chamberlain | Liberal | ||
| nay | Robillard | Liberal | ||
| nay | Owen | Liberal | ||
| nay | Peterson | Liberal | ||
| nay | Graham | Liberal | ||
| nay | Gauthier | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | Lapierre | Liberal | ||
| nay | Fontana | Liberal | ||
| nay | Adams | Liberal | ||
| nay | Alcock | Liberal | ||
| nay | Anderson | Liberal | ||
| nay | Augustine | Liberal | ||
| nay | Bakopanos | Liberal | ||
| nay | Blondin-Andrew | Liberal | ||
| nay | Boudria | Liberal | ||
| nay | Boulianne | Bloc Québécois | ||
| Bradshaw | Liberal | |||
| yea | Broadbent | NDP | ||
| nay | Bulte | Liberal | ||
| nay | Carr | Liberal | ||
| nay | Carroll | Liberal | ||
| nay | Catterall | Liberal | ||
| nay | Chatters | Conservative | ||
| nay | Cleary | Bloc Québécois | ||
| yea | Desjarlais | Independent | ||
| nay | Desrochers | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | DeVillers | Liberal | ||
| nay | Drouin | Liberal | ||
| nay | Efford | Liberal | ||
| nay | Forseth | Conservative | ||
| nay | Frulla | Liberal | ||
| nay | Gagnon | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | Gallaway | Liberal | ||
| nay | Godbout | Liberal | ||
| nay | Gouk | Conservative | ||
| nay | Grewal | Conservative | ||
| nay | Harrison | Conservative | ||
| nay | Ianno | Liberal | ||
| nay | Johnston | Conservative | ||
| nay | Lastewka | Liberal | ||
| nay | Longfield | Liberal | ||
| nay | Macklin | Liberal | ||
| nay | Marceau | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | McLellan | Liberal | ||
| nay | Mitchell | Liberal | ||
| nay | Myers | Liberal | ||
| nay | O'Brien | Independent | ||
| nay | Parrish | Independent | ||
| nay | Penson | Conservative | ||
| nay | Pettigrew | Liberal | ||
| nay | Phinney | Liberal | ||
| nay | Pickard | Liberal | ||
| Poirier-Rivard | Bloc Québécois | |||
| nay | Powers | Liberal | ||
| nay | Reynolds | Conservative | ||
| nay | Saada | Liberal | ||
| nay | Savoy | Liberal | ||
| nay | Schmidt | Conservative | ||
| nay | Simard | Bloc Québécois | ||
| nay | Smith | Liberal | ||
| Torsney | Liberal | |||
| nay | Ur | Liberal | ||
| nay | Valeri | Liberal | ||
| O'Brien | Liberal |